The Rumsey - Swartwood Cemetery is in the Town of Van Etten, Chemung County, New York, being situated on the south side of State Highway 224 behind the farm house of Murray Schoonmaker. It is located about 1/10th of a mile west of the intersection of Route 224 and County Highway 3 (the Wyncoop Creek Road), laying between Cayuta Creek and the abandoned right-of-way of the Lehigh Valley main line. It is not visible from the highway. An abandoned cemetery, it has lacked any care or attention for well over 50 years. An investigation may reveal that the Town of Van Etten is responsible for the cutting of the brush and the mowing of the weeds at least twice a year. The tombstones, on the other hand, are the obligation of the descendants of those persons interred there.
In 1932 the cemetery was grown to brush, trees and high grass. In 1979 the same conditions prevail - rotting tree limbs, brush and weeds, and a thick matting of heavy grass covering the entire plot. Most of the tombstones lay upon the ground and there may be others hidden from sight under the grass and litter. Undoubtedly there are numerous unmarked graves.
The data on all the tombstones found was copied on October 23, 1979, by Joseph & Doris Boyd. To read much of the data on the markers it was necessary to apply a coating of white chalk.
Information in brackets does not appear on the tombstones, but has been added for general interest. Likewise, the surname for some wives, sons, and/or daughters has been added for the sake of clarity.
| Last Name |
First Name |
Date of Birth |
Date of Death |
Age |
Inscription/Relationship/Comments |
| AMES |
BENJAMIN |
1841 |
08/15/1841 |
5m |
(This is a nice small shale tombstone.) |
|
|
|
|
|
(Next is a shale tombstone laying on the ground with its face scaled away. No data.) |
| DECKER |
JOHN |
1809 |
1899 |
|
"Father" (He was a farmer with 64 acres in the Town of Van Etten in 1868.) |
| DECKER |
MARINDA |
1816 |
1899 |
|
"Mother" (Tombstone is off its base and laying on the ground.) |
| DECKER |
HENRY |
08/12/1847 |
|
|
(No death date.) |
| DECKER |
AUGUSTA S. |
04/27/1847 |
3/11/15 |
|
His wife. |
| DECKER |
JOHN J. |
12/11/1881 |
|
|
(No death date.) |
| DECKER |
NELLIE L. |
10/20/1886 |
|
|
His wife. (No death date.) |
| MCINTYRE |
SOVINA |
|
|
|
See entry for JEREMIAH K. RUMSEY. |
| MCINTYRE |
ZIMRI |
1783 or 1784 |
10/05/1877 |
93y |
|
| MCINTYRE |
ORPHELIA |
1784 or 1785 |
09/29/1865 |
80y |
(Both epitaphs on one tombstone which
lays face-up on the ground.) |
| MOORE |
JANE |
07/31/1823 |
09/07/1840 |
47y 1m 7d |
Wife of EDWARD MOORE. (Not found by Boyd
on 10/23/1979. Data from Staver Record - 1932.) |
| ROSEKRANS |
SARAH M. |
05/15/1835 |
11/04/1862 |
27y 5m 20d |
Wife of NELSON ROSEKRANS. (Tombstone
lays on the ground in 8 small pieces and some data is badly eroded. Death
date and age is from the Staver Record - 1932.) |
| RUMSEY |
JEREMIAH K. |
09/24/1800 |
04/18/1871 |
70y 6m 24d |
|
| RUMSEY |
SOVINA |
11/16/1807 |
1872 |
|
(She was the daughter of ZIMRI &
ORPHELIA MCINTYRE and was married in 1827 in Hector, New York. This is
a large heavy shaft type monument with the shaft laying on the ground.
There may be additional data, but the shaft is too heavy to roll over.) |
| RUMSEY |
MARY ALICE |
1857 |
02/11/1859 |
1y 2m |
Daughter of JAMES & MARY RUMSEY.
(Tombstone not found by Boyd on 10/23/1979. Data from the Staver Record
- 1932.) |
| SMITH |
MARY E. |
|
|
|
(See entry for MARY E. SMITH VREDENBURG.) |
| SWARTWOOD |
ISAIAH |
09/21/1791 |
08/01/1873 |
81y 10m 11d |
|
| SWARTWOOD |
MARY |
01/05/1797 |
12/21/1856 |
59y 11m 16d |
Wife of ISAIAH SWARTWOOD. |
| SWARTWOOD |
GEORGE F. |
05/14/1840 |
02/02/1878 |
|
(A shaft type monument laying on the
ground.) |
| SWARTWOOD |
FAYETTE |
03/14/1858 |
11/10/1861 |
3y 7m 27d |
|
| SWARTWOOD |
JANE |
03/14/1784 |
05/03/1854 |
70y 1m 19d |
Wife of DANIEL SWARTWOOD. (Tombstone
lays face-up on the ground.) |
|
|
|
|
|
Next is a fieldstone tombstone with its
face scaled off. No data. DANIEL SWARTWOOD'S grave? |
| SWARTWOOD |
JOHN |
02/27/1754 |
12/12/1837 |
83y 9m 15d |
(Tombstone not found by Boyd on 10/23/1979.
Data from the Staver Record - 1932. He is reported as being a soldier in
the American Revolution.) |
| SWARTWOOD |
SARAH |
1756 |
09/28/1830 |
73y 10m |
Wife of JOHN SWARTWOOD. (An excellent
shale tombstone laying face-up in the weeds.) |
|
|
|
|
|
Nearby are two shale tombstones with
no data. |
| SWARTWOOD |
JOHN |
1800 or 1801 |
09/19/1875 |
74y |
(Tombstone not found by Boyd on 10/23/1979.
Data from the Staver Record - 1932. He was a constable, owner of the Union
Hotel, and postmaster in Van Etten in 1868.) |
| SWARTWOOD |
NORA |
1869 or 1870 |
10/30/1883 |
13y 10m |
Daughter of KING J. & MARY JANE SWARTWOOD.
(Tombstone not found by Boyd on 10/23/1979. Data from the Rumsey Record
- 1972.) |
| VREDENBURG |
CHARLES |
07/24/1830 |
07/05/1860 |
29y 11m 11d |
(Tombstone lays face-up in the weeds
in three pieces, is broken through the age line and turning black.) |
|
|
|
|
|
Next is a small shale tombstone with
no data. |
| VREDENBURG |
IRA S. |
01/09/1845 |
03/31/1888 |
|
|
| VREDENBURG |
WALDO S. |
10/30/1874 |
05/24/1891 |
16y 6m 24d |
Son of IRA S. & ESTHER B. VREDENBURG. (A shaft type monument laying on the ground. There may be additional data on the shaft, but is too heavy to roll over.) |
| VREDENBURG |
MARY E. SMITH |
1852 or 1853 |
07/12/1877 |
24y |
Wife of ALFRED VREDENBURG. (Tombstone not found by Boyd on 10/23/1979. Data may appear on the fallen IRA S. VREDENBURG monument. Data from the Staver Record - 1932.) |