Cemetery Section
Chemung County, New York
Chemung County NY
Home Page Town of Baldwin Page
Hicks Cemetery, Town of Baldwin, Chemung County, NY
A-L   M-Z and Additions

Read by Doris & Joseph Boyd in 1976
Photos by Joyce M. Tice April 28, 1998

The Hicks Cemetery is located in the eastern part of the town of Baldwin, Chemung County, NY, on the West side of the Wynkoop Creek Road (County Highway #3). It is 1/10th of a mile north of the line separating the towns of Baldwin and Chemung. There May be as many as 30 or 40 unmarked and "lost" graves with some possibly dating back 150 years. All headstones were copied by Doris and Joseph Boyd on Sept. 25, 1976. Burial records were found that have no tombstones marking the graves.

Surname First Name Birthdate Deathdate Age Inscriptions/notes
Mahaffey Ellen M.


See Ellen M. Mahaffey Porter
Manchester Archie 1873 Dec. 25, 1887 14yr. Son of F.P. & L
Manchester Freeman 1836 1915

Manchester Henry 1804/5 Apr. 19, 1886 81yr.
Manchester Sylvia L. June 1812 May 30, 1884 71yr,11mo.
Manchester Joseph  1838 1902

Manchester Melissa 1843 Mar. 20, 1925 85yr. Wife of Joseph. Burial permit states she died in Waverly on date indicated and burial occurred Mar. 22, 1925
Manchester Frankie E. no date given Nov. 20, 1876 3yr. Son of Joseph & Melissa.
Manchester R.C. May 6, 1832 Apr. 15, 1862 29yr,11mo,9da. May have been Civil War Veteran, American flag placed in ground beside tombstone.
Martens P. August Apr. 1, 1878 26-Jun-54 76yr,2mo,25da. Permit indicates he was born in Germany.
Martin Lucy


See Rush Jackson
Mathew Michael Lewis Mar. 25, 1944 Oct. 4, 1945 1yr,6mo,9da. First, middle name from burial permit. Grave marked by funeral director's plaque.
Mathews Esther  1923 July 14, 1962 38yr. Death date from burial permit. Permit states she died in Barton
Mathews Irene F. June 7, 1929 Aug. 12, 1948 19yr,1mo,26da. Burial permit indicates she died in Barton
Mathews Marie 1948 Aug. 25, 1960 12yr. Burial permit provided death date and indicates she died in Rochester.
McDowell Beryl Mrs. Sept. 5, 1875 May 31 1939 63yr,8mo,26da. Death date from burial permit. No tombstone.
McDowell George David Apr. 9, 1862 Nov. 1, 1950 88yr,6mo,23da. Death date from burial permit. No tombstone.
McDowell Grace Cooper 1865 1905

Montgomery Francis Howard 1895 Sept. 20, 1965 70yr.  Burial permit gives death date and states he died in Sayre.
Montgomery Elsie B. 1893 Nov. 21, 1964 71yr. Burial permit gives death date and states she died in Barton
Montgomery Gordon Robert 1929 June 26, 1964 35yr. Burial permit gives death date and provided middle name.
In a message dated 7/8/2012 10:25:43 PM Eastern Daylight Time, haysdidi@cox.net writes:
Hello Joyce,
    I want to take the time to say thank you for your wonderful site. I have used it quite a bit in my research.
        One thing that I need corrected is my Uncle's date of death. Its here cemc/hickscm2.htm
       Gordon Robert Montgomery died June 26 1964 not 1954.  
        I really appreciate your site and have used it quite a bit.   Thank you again
       Thanks Diane Montgomery Hays
Morse Lucy B.


See Lucy B. Putnam.
Morse David W. Sept. 26, 1831 Aug. 20, 1853 21yr,10mo,25da. Second son of M.B. & Tryel. Tombstone contains poem written by deceased on Nov. 16, 1848.
Morse Lydia Adaline Mar. 18, 1835 Sept. 21, 1855 20yr,6mo,3da. Daughter of Michael B. & Tryel.
Morse Olive A. Jul/Aug. 1846 Jan. 21, 1856 9yr,5mo. Daughter of Michael B. & Tryel.
Morse Reuben H. Oct. 24, 1834 Nov. 10, 1854 20yr,17da. Son of Michael B. & Tryel.
Niemi Anna Elizabeth Pelton no date given no date listed 5da. Burial permit gives burial date as Jan. 13, 1930.
Niemi John R. 1877 May 15, 1961 84yr. Death date from burial permit. Gives birthplace as Finland.
Niemi Johanna 1875 Jan. 23, 1960 84yr. Death date from burial permit. Gives birthplace as Finland.
Niemi Arvo 1915 no date listed

Niemi Sima


See Sima Niemi Grover
Olcutt Sarah Freeman Feb. 18, 1827 1904
Mother. Birth date from cemetery record.
Orsborn Mary Ann Jan. 12, 1859 Feb. 13, 1863 4yr,1mo,1da. Daughter of Silas & Phebe.
Palmatier Marica 1810/11 Feb. 17, 1857 46yr. Wife of Francis.
Parks Elsie Martha 1893 Sept. 25, 1976 77yr. Death date from burial permit
Parks Wells J. 1888 Dec. 5, 1962 74yr. Death date from burial permit.
Pasto Emil July 1, 1880 Mar. 22, 1972
Burial permit states he died in Bellefonte, Pa.
Pasto Elizabeth June 23, 1881 Oct. 15, 1967
Burial permit states she was born in Finland and died in Irondequoit, Monroe County, NY.
Pasto Marian Frances 1905 July 27, 1967 61yr. Death date from burial permit.
Pasto Toivo H. June 4, 1903 Jan. 15, 1950 46yr,7mo,11da. Death date from burial permit.
Pillado Antonio no date given Oct. 28, 1976 76yr. Newspaper obituary of Oct. 29, 1976 provided death date and says he died at RD#1, Lockwood, NY.
Porter baby no date given no date listed

Porter Clarence 1895 Dec. 26, 1972 77yr. Death date from burial permit.
Porter Secra 1905 Sept. 21, 1969 64yr. Burial permit states she was born in Wyoming and provides death date.
Porter Ellen M. Mahaffey 1843/44 Oct. 23, 1881 37yr. Wife of Lyman E.
Porter Emmit Dec. 19, 1879 Dec. 29, 1885 6yr,10da. Son of Lyman E. & Mary M.
Porter Everett Dec. 8, 1871 Apr. 16, 1957 85yr,4mo,8da. Death date and age from burial permit.
Porter Lois M. Aug. 19, 1875 June 10, 1910
Wife of Everett.
Porter Lila A. 1895 1897

Porter Margaret E. 1897 1897

Porter Lyman no date given Aug. 1884 9 weeks Son of Lyman & Saloma
Porter Mary E. 1912 1914

Porter Sarah M. 1836/37 May 11, 1859 22yr. Wife of L.E. Porter
Porter Sarah E. Sept/Oct. 1838 Mar. 26, 1854 15yr,5mo. Daughter of William & Deborah.
Porter Sarah J. Apr. 1, 1863 May 4, 1863 1mo,3da. Daughter of L.E. & M.E.
Porter William B. Nov/Dec. 1806 Apr. 8, 1882 75yr,4mo.
Porter Debery July 5, 1812 Feb. 18, 1891
Wife of William B. Spelling of first name is as it appears on tombstone.
Porter William D. 1885 Dec. 25, 1947 62yr. Death date from burial permit.
Porter Flora B. 1889 no date listed

Price Harriett


See Harriett Price Barnes
Putnam Thomas P. July/Aug. 1789 Feb. 10, 1879 89yr,6mo. Veteran of War of 1812.
Putnam Lucy B. 1791/92 Sept. 4, 1865 74yr. Morse Family history states she was the daughter of Jonas & Lucy Nowman of Colesville, Broome County, NY. Tombstone repaired and reset in 1974 by J.C. Boyd.
Relyea Rebecca T. 1928 1905
Tombstone located on Russel Squires Plot.
Reniff Abisha B. Sept. 20, 1822 Apr. 27, 1887

Reniff Anna May 19, 1822 Feb. 2, 1903
Wife of Abisha B.
Reniff Mary Jane July 21, 1856 Dec. 11, 1858
Daughter of Abisha B. & Anna
Reynolds Emerson R. 1931 no date listed

Reynolds Florence Louise 1932 Mar. 24, 1976 43yr. Death date and middle name according to burial permit.
Riddell Ann E. Jan. 8, 1847 May 20, 1891 44yr,4mo,21da. Wife of Frederick.
Ross Alvaretta Kellogg 1899 no date listed
Daughter of David & Almena Ross. Tombstone located on Frank C. Hicks plot.
Rumsey Anna M. Aug. 12, 1868 July 23, 1956 87yr,11mo,11da. Death date from burial permit. States death occurred in Elmira.
Rumsey Emma


See Emma Rumsey Swartout
Sayre Fannie J. 1827/28 May 1, 1873 45yr. Wife of G.T.
Sayre Isadore Oct/Nov. 1861 June 9, 1862 7mo. Daughter of G.T. & Fannie J.
Sayre Frank 1844 1919
Father. Co.C, 141st NY. Inf.Vol.
Sayre Minda 1850 1888
Mother
Sayre Frank A. no date given June 28, 1917 40yr. Date from burial permit. Permit states he died in an accident in Ulyssess, Tompkins County, NY.
Sayre George 1819 1894

Sayre Emma J. Jan. 29, 1853 May 10, 1935 82yr,3mo,11da. Death date from burial permit.
Sayre George Willis Apr. 18, 1877 Dec. 30, 1946 69yr,8mo,12da. Death date from burial permit
Sayre Susie 1886 Oct. 11, 1963 77yr. Death date from burial permit.
Schlier Frank W. 1900 no date listed

Schlier Elsie A. 1901 Dec. 23, 1970 69yr. Death date from burial permit.
Selon John no date given no date listed
Burial date from burial permit is Sept. 28, 1921. Permit states he resided in Hicks.
Sharpsteen baby girl no date given no date listed
Grave marked only by funeral director's plaque stating the infant died in Sayre. Permit has only the date "July 1, 1975"
Shoemaker Allen Peter Mar. 24, 1869 June 5, 1957 88yr,2mo,12da. Death date from burial permit.
Shoemaker Mary Oct. 13, 1869 Mar. 28, 1939 69yr,5mo,15da. Death date from burial permit.
Shoemaker baby boy
Sept. 13, 1950 1da. No tombstone, only funeral director's plaque. Permit is source of death date.
Simmons Donald Edward no date given Aug. 17, 1926
No tombstone, only funeral director's plaque. Permit states he lived in Hicks. Date from permit.
Simmons Lillian no date given Oct. 12, 1927
No tombstone, only funeral director's plaque. Permit states she lived in Hicks. Date from permit.
Smith Gertrude


See Gertrude Smith Grover
Soper Mary E. July/Aug. 1872 May 20, 1876 3yr,9mo. Daughter of Edwin & Alvarella M.
Soper Willie J. Jan/Feb. 1874 May 20, 1876 2yr,3mo. Daughter of Edwin & Alvarella M.
Squires Oliver R. 1824 1909

Squires Sally A. Sept. 15, 1819 May 22, 1887 67yr,8mo,7da. Wife of Oliver R. Separate headstone says "Mother" 1819-1887
Squires Russell 1790/91 1871 80yr. Father.
Squires Martha 1790/91 1869 78yr. Mother.
Stage David May 18, 1824 Apr. 6, 1893

Stage Frances E. 1845 1906
Wife of David
Stage Elizabeth


See Elizabeth Stage Van Horn
Stage Frances M. Oct. 23, 1866 Sept. 30, 1867 11mo,7da. Daughther of David & Elizabeth
Stage John H. Jan/Feb. 1861 May 16, 1861 3mo. Son of David & Frances E.
Stuart D. William Feb. 3, 1861 Oct. 1, 1938 77yr,7mo,28da. Death date from burial permit. Permit states he was born in Millport, NY.
Stuart Matthew J. 1822 1912

Stuart Hulda 1840 1912
Wife of Matthew J.
Sudel Dorothy no date given Dec. 25, 1927
Cemetery record not clear on spelling of Surname. Record indicates death on date indicated.
Swartout Ames no date given no date listed
Small tombstone.
Swartout Emma Rumsey no date given no date listed
Small tombstone.
Swartout Emmeline Banfield no date given no date listed
Small tombstone.
Swartout Eva Apr. 28, 1851 Feb. 19, 1945 93yr,9mo,22da. Sister. Burial permit states she was born in Van Etten, NY.
Swartout Mary no date given Jan. 1, 1916
Sister.
Swayze Asa A. 1890 Feb. 26, 1962 71yr. Burial permit provided death date and that he died in Barton.
Swayze Viva Blanche 1891 Oct. 19, 1969 78yr. Death date from burial permit. Wife of Asa A.
Swayze Catherine no date given Nov. 20, 1954
Death date from burial permit. Grave marked by funeral director's plaque.
Sweet Elizabeth


See Elizabeth S. Dilly
Sweet Elizabeth 1791/92 Nov 22, 1863 71yr. Tombstone broken in two pieces.
Sweet Jacob D. June 12, 1845 Feb. 13, 1899

Sweet Mary B. 1847 1910
Second tombstone for her also located here.
Sweet Thomas M. 1900 1903
Tombstone has no surname but is assumed to be Sweet as it is located on the Sweet plot.
Tarbell William July 28, 1858 Mar. 14, 1916
Birthdate from Towner's "History of Chemung County" and states he was born in Chemung Center. It also states he was a farmer in Baldwin in 1891. Death date from burial permit which states he died in Chemung Center.
Tarbell Maggie 1858 Jan. 14, 1944 86yr. Burial permit states she died in Indianapolis, Indiana on date indicated. Towner's "History of Chemung County" states she was the daughter of Samuel & Sarah Cumber and married Dec. 15, 1883.
Tarbell Zachariah 1791 1869
Towner's "History of Chemung County" states he was born in Chenango County, NY. and arrived in the Town of Chemung in 1853. Also states he fought in War of 1812.
Tarbell Anna A. 1823 1911
Wife of Zachariah. Towner's "History of Chemung County" states her maiden name was "Dings".
Taubman Susan Tillman 1866 Jan. 1, 1961 94yr. Death date from burial permit. Epitaph appears on same stone as Celestia M. Tillman.
Theetge John W. Dec. 11, 1864 no date listed
Burial permit states burial occurred Jan. 28, 1923. Towner's "History of Chemung County" states he was born Dec. 11, 1864 and the son of Daniel L. & Emeline Wheat Theetge.
Theetge Belle Goldsmith 1852 no date listed 78yr. Wife of John W. Burial permit indicates burial occurred on Mar. 8, 1930.
Thomas Amarilla Loomis Aug. 12, 1852 June 6, 1897
Wife of H.S. Thomas
Thompson Henry no date given no date listed

Thompson Susan no date given no date listed

Thompson Mahala no date given no date listed

Thompson Zelia no date given no date listed

Tillman Celestia K. Mar/Apr. 1885 May 2, 1937 82yr,1mo. Death date from burial permit. Date is on same tombstone with Susan Tillman Taubman. Cemetery record lists her as "Kittie".
Tillman Peter M. Nov. 5, 1827 Dec. 16, 1873 46yr,1mo,11da.
Tillman Harriet Aug. 30, 1832 Aug. 29, 1908
"Mother"
Tillman Susan


See entry for Susan Tillman Taubman
Tillman William Mar. 2, 1780 May 6, 1864 84yr,2mo,4da. Stone lays on ground, broken into two pieces
Tillman Anna Feb. 4, 1784 Jan. 12, 1873 88yr,11mo,8da. Wife of William
Utter Silas 1846/47 Apr. 30, 1916 69yr. No Tombstone. Death date from burial permit. Permit states he died at Hector, NY.
Van Horn Chris Andrew May 11, 1954 May 23, 1954 12da. A small tombstone exists with "baby" printed on it. Death date taken from burial permit.
Van Horn Elizabeth Stage 1897 no date listed
"Bell"
Van Horn Lottie Bailey 1929 Feb. 28, 1971 42yr. Death date from burial permit.
Van Etten George B. Dec. 13, 1857 Jan. 30, 1863 5yr,1mo,17da. Son of Miron & Lucy A. (Miron is spelled as it appears on tombstone.
Van Etten Lucy A. no date given Mar. 15, 1861
Age cannot be read because tombstone was reset in a concrete base that covered the dates.
Van Laren Bessie May July 1, 1895 Feb. 3, 1940 45yr,7mo,2da. No tombstone. Death date from burial permit. Cemetery record states she was born in Erin and was buried Feb. 7, 1940.
Van Luven Floyd Aug. 11, 1885 Jan. 24, 1942 56yr,5mo,13da. No tombstone. Death date from burial permit. Glenn Culver of the Wynkoop Creek Road states that he hung himself in the jail in Elmira.
Varga Nicholas July 7, 1896 Sept. 30, 1934 38yr,2mo,23da. Death date from burial permit. Permit states he was born in Hungary and died in Barton.
Varga Esther 1896 Dec. 17, 1968 72yr. Death date from burial permit. Permit states she was born in Hungary.
Varga Elles 1898 Feb. 28, 1965
"Brother". Death date from burial permit. Permit states he died in Marion, Virginia.
Vargo John 1929 no date listed

Vargo Barbara J. 1930 no date listed

Wales Hannah Feb. 15, 1812 Sept. 10, 1895

Wales Ira Nov. 4, 1787 Nov. 25, 1882 95yr,21da.
Weeks Clara E. Nov/Dec. 1886 Apr. 27, 1888 1yr,4mo. Daughter of J.W. & F.
Weeks Ealm S. 1866 1901
Father
Weeks Ella T. Apr. 2, 1870 Nov. 15, 1940 70yr,7mo,13da. Mother. Death date from burial permit. Permit states she died in Elmira Heights and lists her as Ella T. Houck.
Weeks Senaca May 1, 1833 Feb. 10, 1883 49yr,9mo,9da. First name as spelled on Tombstone.
Weeks Eleanor A. May 18, 1835 Dec. 1, 1872 37yr,6mo,13da. Wife of Seneca
Westbrook Francis Apr. 30, 1850 June 12, 1876 26yr,1mo,12da. Killed by lightning. Son of John & Phebe.
Wheat Emeline


See entry for John W. Theetge
Wilber Theda 1804/5 Apr. 6, 1887 82yr. Wife of William, Daughter of Jesse & Zilpay Loomis. Epitaph appears on the shaft-type Loomis monument.
Woodhouse Frankie Pearl Dec. 15, 1888 Sept. 30, 1889 9mo,15da. Daughter of Amos & Nora. Small tombstone.
Wrightman twin babies no date given no date listed
babies of T. & E. A small tombstone.
Wrightman Ellen 1847 1927
Cemetery record list her as "Mrs. Emina" and states she was buried on Apr. 28, 1927.
Young William H. Nov. 23, 1831 July 26, 1901

Young Harriet Oct. 28, 1838 Oct. 23, 1894
Wife of William H.
Young Theadore W. Oct. 14, 1868 Nov. 15, 1900
Theadore is spelling as it appears on monument.

Additions sent in by Ray Matthews


Last First, Middle or REAL Date of Birth Date of Death "Inscription" - (Notes)
ARGETSINGER Hilda 1918


Henry 1906 1982

Merton 1907 1973

Philip 1900 1988 "Married Dec. 2, 1922"

Pauline 1906 1966 (Philip's wife)
BARTON Addie M. 1920 1993

Charles E. 1921

BOGART David R. Jr. July 2, 1973 June 22, 1990 "Beloved Son, Brother, Uncle"
BROWN Herman C. 1912 1983

Dora B. 1920

CLARK Margaret E. 1923 1982

Charles E. 1919

CUNDY Norman Feb. 19, 1926 Mar. 1, 1991 "Norman Cundy SSGT US Air Force World War II Korea Feb. 19, 1926 - Mar. 1, 1991" (plaque)

Betty KOOP Apr. 4, 1929


Richard Feb. 21, 1924 Jun. 23, 1985 "PFC US Army World War II"

Robert Sr. Dec. 12, 1913 Sep. 11, 1977 "US Navy"
DOANE Emma Mary SAYRE 1919 1978
EVANS Arthur M. 1915 1990 (Barber Funeral Home marker beside the stone)

Nellie L. 1918

FLORA Charles E. 1916 1974

Pearl M. 1915 1998

Timothy 1951 1981
GROVER Byron L. 1935 1995 "EPH. 4.29"

Jean A. 1940

HARRINGTON James Keith 1922 1983

Betsy Vivien GROVES 1919
"His Wife" (married to James K. Harrington)
LEE Robert A. 1904 1980

Charlotte 1922

LEWIS Stanley 1921 1991 (Candor Monument Service marker)
McMINDS James Joseph, Jr. Aug. 25, 1946
"Oct 15, 1977" (two rings)

Mary CAMPBELL Sept. 27, 1938

NILES John Feb. 14, 1910 Mar. 1, 1992 "TEC 5 US Army World War II"
PARKS Donald E. Nov. 5, 1913 Dec. 15, 1993 "TEC 5 US Army World War II"
PIPER Windsor Montana Sept. 25, 1921 Sept. 5, 1994 "Windsor M. Piper US Navy 1921 - 1994" (plaque)

Marion BODINE March 9, 1915

SAYRE Albert J. April 8, 1906 April 28, 1989 "Apr. 22, 1944" (two rings)

Evelyn M. Dec. 31, 1922

SCAIFE Frederick W. 1918 1993

Mildred E. 1922

SHOEMAKER Harold 1910 1995

Cora 1914

STONE Cleveland 1914 1983 (Arnold Funeral Home marker)
ST. PIERRE Maurice J. Nov. 22, 1930 Apr. 22, 1996 "EM3 US Navy Korea" (plague)
SWARTOUT Robert E. Sr. Jan. 5, 1948 Dec. 9, 1983 "SP4 US Army Vietnam" (plaque)
TALADA Richard A. Sr. 1959 1981 "Richard A. Talada Sr. Nov. 30, 1959 - Feb. 17, 1981 - SGT US Marine Corps" (plaque)

Esther M. 1959 1981 (Richard, Sr.'s wife)
WEST William J. Aug. 28, 1921 Aug. 6, 1994 "SGT US Army World War II" (plaque)
WIESNER Barbara Jean ECK 1932 1983 "Wife, Mother, Friend to All"

Robert P. 1925

WOOD Ernest E. Nov. 26, 1922 Nov. 14, 1986 "PFC US Army Air Corps World War II"

Mary C. 1927

Subj: Addition & correction
Date: 03/22/2002 5:41:11 PM Eastern Standard Time
From: drumse@netzero.net (DRumsey)
To: Joyce Tice

Hi Joyce,
I have just visited some of your sites.  You are doing an excellent job.

I thought that I had observed a link to make additions or corrections but can not find it now.  I am a descendant of Rev. Earl Rumsey of the Simon line.  An entry for Josiah V. Rumsey, buried in the Westbrook Cemetery, Van Etten, Chemung, is in error.  He is the son of George W. & Rachel Ann Steenburgh.  Dates for Emma Rumsey Swartout in the Hicks Cemetery, Baldwin, Chemung are 16 May 1862-Nov 1884, two years after her marriage.

I correspond with Jean Rumsey quite often. I called her earlier this week and she is fairing quite well. Her 90th birthday is 24 May 2002.

Thanks for all the good work.

Douglas Rumsey

Hi, Joyce,
I wonder if you'd like to add the obituary for Marguerite Vargo
Montgomery which I will add to the end of this email.  She's buried in
Hicks Cemetery in Chemung County.  She was a friend of my parents.

Also I wonder if the Nicholas and Esther Varga listed in the cemetery
transcription might actually be VargO, because in Marguerite's obit it
says she was the daughter of late Nicholas and Esther (Orsurvath)
Vargo.  For what it's worth, the family is Vargo in the 1930 census,
too. 

I love your huge site.  I think you have the most useful data of all the Rootsweb sites!
Thanks!
Trudi (Rautio) Short
 
 

Published On Site On 4/28/98
By Joyce M. Tice


You are our welcome visitor since April 27, 1998. Page relocated & Counter reset 08 DEC 2004